Milk

"My name is Harvey Milk, and I want to recruit you!"

So begins the triumphant rise and subsequent tragedy of Harvey Milk - the first openly gay official to be elected to public office in 1978. This stirring biopic on Milk's pivotal quest for gay rights, drives home important messages, but resonates less than hoped for.

In 1970, life still has a few surprises left for Harvey Milk (Sean Penn). On the cusp of turning 40, he picks up Scott Smith (James Franco) at a subway station, falls in love, and decides to come out of the closet. The couple set up home and shop in San Francisco's Castro Street, which soon becomes a thriving hotbed for the gay community. Amidst brewing anti-gay persecution, Milk feels compelled to make a stand, and runs for District Supervisor.

Albeit unsuccessful, his impassioned activism opens up a wave of homosexual liberation and openness. Finally, in 1977, Milk's campaign hits a breakthrough, and he ascends to San Francisco City Supervisor. After initial efforts to coordinate with fellow Supervisor Dan White (Josh Brolin) sours, Milk finds himself paying the price for his passionate dedication to gay rights.

Almost as if he's born to play Milk, Penn disappears into the role with empathy and powerful conviction. He infuses Milk's courage and determination with winning charisma and tender vulnerability; always dignified and graceful. Brolin makes White a character to sympathize with, giving him an unexpected human touch, and putting forth a fair portrayal that doesn't turn into a stereotype.

Among the supporting cast of Milk's lovers and supporters, Franco is subtle and low-key, while Diego Luna (as Jack) is flamboyant and erratic, unfortunately over-emphasizing gayness just a tad. Emile Hirsch (as Cleve Jones) though, brings an energetic exuberance that is rather refreshing.

Milk is poignant enough, with an astute mix of recreated newsreel footage thrown in that lends weight and historical significance. Yet the weakest link is the tangible detachment of director Gus Van Sant, who fails to bring life fully to Milk's inspirational spirit. You walk away feeling moved, but not necessarily satisfied.

by mtvasia.com